How We Test and Rate

Every review on Bitcoin.diy is written and signed by Martijn Mijnders, founder and editor. This page explains how we decide what to recommend, what a score means and how we earn money, so you can judge our reviews for yourself.

Last updated 22 November 2026

Two Kinds of Review

Hands-on review

We have used the product ourselves: set it up, moved real bitcoin and checked the claims. Hands-on reviews show our own photos, the firmware or app version and the date of the test.

Research review

We have not used the product enough to call it hands-on. The review rests on the maker's documentation and source code, published security disclosures and independent checks. It carries a visible research review label.

We do not present a research review as a hands-on test. When we do test a product by hand later, the review gets a dated hands-on section and the label changes. Older reviews are being brought up to this standard one by one, starting with the devices we own.

What We Check

Hardware wallets

  • +Security architecture: secure element and its certification, how the seed is generated, PIN and passphrase options, duress and decoy features.
  • +Can you verify it? Whether the firmware is open source and whether independent verifiers have rebuilt the current release byte for byte, with the version and date (we use WalletScrutiny).
  • +Bitcoin-only discipline: is there Bitcoin-only firmware, is it locked or just a setting.
  • +Air-gap and connectivity: QR, microSD, USB, Bluetooth and NFC, and whether radios can be avoided.
  • +Software: does it work with Sparrow and other Bitcoin wallets, or only with the vendor app.
  • +Track record: disclosed vulnerabilities, how the company responded, data breaches and who funds it.
  • +Price: the price in the maker's own store, with the date we checked it.

Exchanges and apps

  • +Real costs: trading fees, spread and withdrawal fees, not only the headline rate.
  • +Custody: can you withdraw to your own wallet, Lightning support, proof of reserves.
  • +Regulation: licences that apply to you (for example MiCA in the EU), KYC requirements and enforcement history.
  • +Incident history: hacks, frozen withdrawals and how they were handled.

Bitcoin-backed loans

  • +Custody model: multisig where you hold a key, segregated custody or pooled custody.
  • +Rehypothecation: is your collateral lent out again, and can we confirm that.
  • +Total cost: APR, origination and other fees, loan-to-value and what happens at a margin call.
  • +Regulatory and solvency record, including the 2022 lender failures.

We focus on Bitcoin. If a product is built mainly for other coins, that counts against it in a review here, even if it is good at what it does.

How Scores Work

Scores run from 1 to 10. Each review shows a rating breakdown by category and the overall score is the average of those categories, so you can see exactly where a product gains and loses points. The same overall score appears everywhere we mention the product.

Scores move when the facts move. Two recent examples:

  • +The OneKey Classic 1S Pure went from 7.5 to 8 after an independent verifier rebuilt its firmware and got an exact match with what OneKey ships.
  • +The Coldcard Q and Mk5 each dropped from 8 to 7.5 in November 2026, when Coinkite raised their prices and value for money no longer held up.

An affiliate deal never changes a score. Products we earn nothing from are scored the same way.

Keeping Reviews Current

Prices, fees and firmware change constantly. Every review shows when it was last updated and we recheck prices in the maker's own store, noting the date we checked. Sales such as Black Friday are mentioned separately from the regular price. When a security issue is disclosed, we update the affected reviews and say what owners should do.

Corrections

When we get something wrong, we fix it and, where it matters for your decision, say so in the review. If you spot an error, email with a source and we will check it.

How We Make Money

Through affiliate links and clearly labelled advertising. If you buy through one of our links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Paid placements are marked as sponsored. We do not sell reviews or scores. Full details are in our affiliate disclosure.

Review Units

Some makers send us a product to test. Every review that uses a free unit says so. Makers do not see a review before it is published and they cannot change it afterwards.

More about the person behind the reviews on the author page. Start with our reviews or the hardware wallet comparison.